Green Lantern
Directed by: Martin Campbell
Cast: Ryan Reynolds as Hal Jordan / Green Lantern
Blake Lively as Carrol Ferris
Peter Sarsgaard as Hector Hammond
Rated PG-13
*The following may contain spoilers*
I feel like I should be clear here, since I respect you guys and all. Here it goes: I am not a fan of Green Lantern. For some reason, the idea of a guy running around with a glowing piece of jewelry that allows him to make anything he thinks of appear into thin air never appealed to me. I know, I’m a weird kid. Thankfully though, my brother and best friend are way into the Green Lantern, so I’ve heard the origin, main villains and plot points of the Green Lantern comics dozens of times. However, no amount of reiterations could have prepared me for Ryan Reynold’s portrayal of the classic hero.
Green Lantern tells the story of Hal Jordan, an “ordinary” jet fighter pilot, who’s life gets turned upside down when he’s given a green power ring by a dying purple alien (don’t worry, that was all in the trailer). A bunch of other stuff happens, all while I suffered through a bad plot, terrible acting and classic character destruction, but we’ll get to that later. All you really need to know is that, by choosing him, the ring catapulted Hal into an elite group of galactic protectors called the Green Lanterns. And adventures ensue!
What I Liked:
I've got to give the movie credit, it did a fantastic job with the special effects. The green creations from Hal's ring looked really cool and were actually pretty believable, while retaining the comedic and classically campy feel of the comic books. Plus, when you combine Hal's imagined weapons with the villains telepathy, it makes for some rocking awesome battle sequences. Not gonna lie, I appreciated it.
What I Didn't Like:
Alright, here comes the long and painful part. I'd like to apologize to any fans of the Lantern, specifically those friends and brothers of mine, because this is going to be harsh.
Let's just break down the horribleness into two sections: Plot and Characters.
Plot:
The movie started out pretty strong, explaining the Green Lantern core through a cool-looking montage in the beginning, followed by a pretty awesome battle scene between a Lantern Core member (not Hal, but the alien who gave him the ring) and the main villain, Pharalax, the embodiment of fear, which leaves the Core member mortally wounded and soaring towards the nearest planet...which just so happens to be Earth. Go figure.
Then it starts to smell.
After the strong opening, we get several shots of Hal being a punk and then a 30 minute plane battle that had nothing to do with the plot whatsoever, save for setting up a very weird and unclear backstory and acting as "foreshadowing" for the final battle.
On top of that, the plot seemed to be full of holes, a fact not helped by the lack of acting shown by the entire cast and a terrible script. When Ryan Reynold's is the best actor in the movie, you have a problem.
For example, when Hal first meets the alien who gives him the ring, he is first transported an unspecified distance by a giant glowing orb of green energy and then drops him into a puddle...and he has no reaction. Instead, he just strides over to the crashed alien spacecraft and pulls the purple dude out of the cockpit, again with no reaction.
The scene only gets worse when it pulls in the analyst from the flight company, who is apparently Hal's best friend. There was no previous implication of this friendship, yet the nerd is apparently the first guy that Hal calls in the event of meeting an alien.
On top of unexplained character relationships, the film is littered with ill-fitting dialogue, throwing in cheesy lines in otherwise serious scenes. Drawing again from scene mentioned above, when Hal tells his surprise friend that the dead alien gave him a ring, the nerd responded with, "He proposed?!" Sure, it was kind of funny, but drastically took away from the already weak scene.
Scenes and dialogue like this lay scattered throughout the movie, leaving an odd, broken and jumpy feeling to the film and a sour taste in my mouth after it was all over.
Characters:
There's no way around it, the characters in the film make the movie, even more so in those based on comic books. However, when all of your stars decide they're just not going to actually act in the movie, the characters lose a bit of their life force. Unfortunately, that's what happened in this movie.
As I mentioned above, Ryan Reynolds is the best actor in this movie. And while that's great for his career, it doesn't do much for the audience.
For example, Blake Lively is a decent actress, with a career of her own. She's not a no-name and it's obvious from the beginning that she isn't just another pretty face. She's a real woman; well rounded as a jet pilot and about to be made the CEO of the aircraft company, and she's not obnoxiously obsessed with Hal. Yet, for some unknown reason, she chose to deliver all of her lines like she had a lemon in her mouth. As a result, she went from a real person to a "filler-character" the second she opened her mouth. And none of the other portrayals got any better.
No matter how much I couldn't get into the Green Lantern as a kid, I always respected Hal Jordan, the man behind the suit. He always seemed better than most, the man we all aspire to be. He is the embodiment of goodness and that's the whole reason the ring chose him in the first place. Keep in mind, this is my perception. There are probably emotional problems he faces in the comics as well.
The point is, i walked in expecting Hal Jordan to be fearless, heroic and a little witty and smart. Instead, I got Ryan Reynolds waking up with a nameless girl, dropping a terrible line and racing to work, calling another driver an a-hole after Hal almost drives into the man. So much for being a better person.
Instead of the Hal Jordan I expected, I got an unlikable Tony Stark.
![]() |
| Minus the stache. |
So, yeah. Total destruction of a classic character. Thanks, Hollywood.
I'd also like to go into the relationships of the characters a little bit more. It's not just Hal and the nerd that are never explained, it's everyone. Through only mentions throughout the movie, the audience is forced to piece together the reasons why the only human characters with lines have known each other their entire lives, though it's never completely explained.
Overall, I found myself bored and irritated by the human's interactions with each other as they continued to be confusing and boring, filled with cheesy dialogue and terrible foreshadowing.
Honestly, I could go on, but i think I'll quiet my rant for the night.
Final Thoughts:
I really shouldn't be surprised; Hollywood has a knack for making good things terrible. However, despite the other critics and my own apparent hatred of the film, the fans of Green Lantern seem to be eating it up. I know my friends loved it, and, honestly, I can see where they're coming from. For some reason, Green Lantern is endearing. It carries a certain charm that even had me overlooking it's awfulness a few times.
Green Lantern won't win any awards. Heck, it probably wouldn't even have made it out the door of a basic film making class. But there was something about it that kept you watching and cheering for him until the very end. I guess Ryan Reynold's captured Hal Jordan's charm after all.
![]() |
| Oh boy... |
When Should You See It?
Despite my ending comments, I really didn't like the movie. Wait for the DVD if you absolutely have to see it.
Personal Rating: 3 of 10
Plot: 2 of 10
Sexuality/Sensuality: 1 of 10
Language: 2 of 10
For an apparent kids movie, the language was kind of rough, with two uses of a-hole and two of GD in the first ten minutes, proving further that the movie really couldn't decide whether it wanted to be Spider Man or Christopher Nolan's Batman.









